Whos afraid of banning corporal punishment of children. Flanigan and edwin fogelman the causes and consequences of political violence have become major topics of research in an era of history beset by seemingly continual warfare, revolution, and other violent acts of every description. Thomas hobbes of punishments and rewards a punishment, is an evil1 inflicted by publique authority, on him that hath done, or omitted that which is iudged by the same au. The novel appeared monthly over the course of 1866, and it was a smash hit. This barcode number lets you verify that youre getting exactly the right version or edition of a. A comparative analysis of prison riots at chatham 1861 and dartmoor 1932. These resources can serve as a study aid for classwork or exams. A comparative historical perspective this book identifies and examines the sources of similarities and differences in types of economic punishments, incapacitation. Comparative historical analysis research papers academia. Part of thecriminal law commons,criminology commons, and thecriminology and criminal justice commons this article is brought to you for free and open access by northwestern university school of law scholarly commons. Historical perspective on punishment and social structure chapter 2 what determines type of punishment.
Pdf comparative and historical perspectives in economic. Comparativehistorical methods sage publications ltd. Children in historical and comparative perspective. Those are paths leading to a better characterization of a specific region within europe, whose constituent countries share a number of similar features in their monetary and financial past. Capital punishment is a legal penalty in the china of the peoples republic of china. We anticipate doing so will demonstrate the value of a comparative historical perspective for studying crime, deviance, and punishment. Article information, pdf download for crossnational variability in capital punishment, open. In each issue of origins, an academic expert will analyze a particular current issue political, cultural, or social in a larger, deeper context. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Punishment in this unique textbook, which is scholarly yet accessible to students, miethe and lu approach punishment from a perspective that is both historical and comparative, addressing the global dimensions of punishment as few authors do.
Many school districts have banned it, and many child advocates recommend that parents no longer spank or strike their children. Botched executions and americas death penalty, published by stanford university press, discussed the subject on. Philosophical analysis of the theories of punishment in. Comparative study of parental involvement and private tuition. It sets out an intellectual history of comparative historical analysis and presents the main methodological techniques employed by researchers, including. The term crime does not, in modern criminal law, have any simple and universally accepted definition,1 though statutory definitions have been provided for. The history of punishment by lewis lyons, published by amber books, 2003. Children in historical and comparative perspective presents the work of many of the worlds foremost authorities on the subject in a study that affirms the importance of the role children play in the story of civilization. A comparative historical perspective by terance miethe author isbn. Miethe, hong lu this book identifies and examines the sources of similarities and differences in types of economic punishments, incapacitation devices and structures, and lethal and nonlethal forms of corporal punishment over time and place. Pdf comparative historical analysis in the social sciences.
Baby dumping, comparative study, legislation, prevention, punishment. These methods put historical time and crosscultural variation at the center of the research question, data collection and data analysis. Through this comparative historical perspective, the reader should gain an appreciation of the universal and contextspeci. It has appeared in print annually since 1977 and is currently sponsored by the franklin college of arts and sciences and the willson center for the humanitites and the university of georgia. During the year 1866 only crime and punishment was being read, only it was being spoken about by fans of literature, who often complained about the stifling power of the novel and the painful impression it left which caused people with strong nerves to risk illness and. Stepbrothers rules by renee rose, hero to obey anthology by selena kitt, rocky mountain rogue by lee savino, rocky.
Alexander had freed the russian serfs in 1861 and began a progressive social and economic reform movement in an attempt to. Warren stearns follow this and additional works at. Since this study was concerned with the effects of death qualification on. Historical perspective of education and thecurriculum of the philippines leonilita ferrerbadillo 2. The early mesopotamian cultures were perhaps the first organized civilizations with permanent residences.
Summary of research on the effects of corporal punishment. A comparative and historical analysis christopher j. Historical perspective of education and the curriculum of. Historical context in crime and punishment owl eyes. Miethe and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Punishment comparative historical perspective criminology. Corporal punishment is a way to discipline and raise children, but it depends on the parents communication with their child as they act upon physically causing pain as the consequence of their misbehavior. Bibliography 1 north american slavery in comparative perspective. The study adopts a comparative historical framework based on what amenta and hicks 2010 refer to as deep knowledge social policy case studies ireland and ghana to illustrate tensions in different countries between normative child welfare initiatives and religious, customary family ideologies. Most dutch historians hold quite a different view on dutch historical consciousness before, during, and after 1995. Use the lessons in this chapter to learn more about the literary and historical context of dostoyevskys crime and punishment. First published in the russian messenger, a notable magazine in the 19th century, crime and punishment was officially published in 1867 and was greeted with acclaim. A comparative historical perspective terance miethe on amazon. The comparatist is a sponsored journal of the southern comparative literature association.
What is the relation between comparative historical analysis. The history of punishment by lewis lyons, published by. Granatsteins observations on holland in 1995 are remarkable, to say the least. Philosophical analysis of the theories of punishment in the context of nigerian educational system doi. Philosophical analysis of the theories of punishment in the. Whatever your opinion on the death penalty is, there is no doubt that the three mishandled executions this past year most recently this week in arizona were an unpleasant reminder of the complex nature of the law itself. It sets out an intellectual history of comparativehistorical analysis and presents the main methodological techniques employed by researchers, including. A consensual theory of punishment underlying most discussions of the justification of punishment is a di lemma pitting a certain general conception of the aims of a liberal and rational system of criminal law against intuitions about distinctions and requirements that this system ought to take into account. This research work was focused on the comparative study of parental involvement and private tuition regarding educational attainments of students at secondary school level.
Sources for teaching, research, and general background bibliographies. Mar 30, 2012 in recent years, comparative historical analysis cha has been developed as a methodological apparatus that is distinct from quantitative research in many respects. Perspectives on punishment the contours of control edited by sarah armstrong and lesley mcara. Reinventing punishment a comparative history of criminology and penology. The selection of capital juries 123 study of juror decision making.
The use of capital punishment is active in most east asian countries, including china, taiwan, japan, north korea, malaysia, thailand. E inolf university of virginia torture was formally abolished by european governments in the 19th century, and the actual practice of torture decreased as well during that period. Generally, it involves comparisons of social processes across times and places. Oct 24, 2011 historical perspective of education and thecurriculum of the philippines leonilita ferrerbadillo 2. Oxford university press is a department of the university of oxford. Miethe, professor of criminal justice terance d miethe, hong lu cambridge university press, 2005 social science 240 pages. What is the relation between comparative historical.
The contributors discuss corporal punishment, its use, causes, and consequences, drawing on a wide array of comparative, psychological, and sociological theories. Corporal punishment is a common way of discipline in parenting, whether. The term crime does not, in modern criminal law, have any simple and universally accepted definition,1 though statutory definitions have been provided for certain purposes. In this book, social theorist michael donnelly and family violence expert murray a. While this is correct, it is less apparent to what extent cha is different from and adds something to the tools and techniques known from ordinary case study research i. Punishment and control in historical perspective h. View history of literature as a discipline research papers on academia. Perspectives on punishment paperback sarah armstrong. The history of punishment by lewis lyons, published by amber.
Crime and punishment was published in 1866 and is one of dostoevskys four great masterpieces, murder stories all. A comparative historical perspective miethe, terance on. A sample of 80 students of 10th class from ten different secondary schools was taken. The contributors represent many nations as well as a variety of disciplines, from the social sciences to history and the arts. View comparative historical analysis research papers on academia. Punishment and control in historical perspective springerlink. Legal scholar austin sarat, author of gruesome spectacles. There is an enormous academic and popular literature on punishment. A historical perspective of americas death penalty. Historical perspective on punishment and social structure.
It furthers the universitys objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide. The development of curriculum in history is basically founded on five outstanding motives religion mass education political excellence in utilitarian education. Introductory there is a prevailing antinomy xut the philosophical justification of punishment. A comparative historical perspective this book identifies and examines the sources of similarities and differences in types of. In recent years, comparative historical analysis cha has been developed as a methodological apparatus that is distinct from quantitative research in many respects. Corporal punishment of children in theoretical perspective.
Together, they clarify the analytical issues and lay a strong foundation for future research and interdisciplinary collaboration. Changes in punishment should not be viewed solely through the lens of progressreform or as a cyclical patternpendulum systems of punishment can only be understood within a societys social, political, ideological, and economic context. Comparative study of parental involvement and private. This book is designed to identify and examine the sources of similarity and differences in types of economic punishments, incapacitation devices and structures, and lethal and nonlethal forms of corporal punishment over time and place. History of literature as a discipline research papers. Hong lu informed by current scholarship, yet tailored to the. The use of corporal punishment for the education of a child is one of the most loaded and disputed questions among jurists, psychologists, sociologists, educators, and the general public. The authors look closely at punishment responses to crime and deviance across different regions of the world and in specific countries like the united states. Guided by existing macrolevel theories on punishment and society, the. Murder in crime and punishment was for personal ambition.
From the perspective of the comparative historical tradition, the universalizing programs of the past and present ranging from struc tural functionalism and systems theory in the 1960s and. Qualitative and quantitative approaches, 4 th edition. It provides a brief historical perspective of the postapartheid south african education system with primary emphasis placed upon the management of discipline in secondary schools. The early history of punishment begins with gildamesh, the samarian king of uruk, who reigned around 2700 bc. Includes a mixture of both empirical research and theoretical perspectives. In the 20th century, however, torture became much more common. Petersburg, russia, under the reign of tsar alexander ii. Perspectives on punishment hardcover sarah armstrong. It is mostly enforced for murder and drug trafficking, and executions are carried out by lethal injection or gun shot. A historical perspective is used to shed some light on current policy and practice. Hong lu informed by current scholarship, yet tailored to the needs of undergraduate students, this textbook presents a broad perspective on one of the most fundamental social practices.
In addition to the analysis provided by each months feature, origins will also include images, maps, graphs and other material to complement the essay. Pdf welfare and punishment in comparative perspective. Welfare and punishment in comparative perspective the past three decades of work on the soci al analysis of punishment have arguably neglected the impact of the commitment to welfare on the scale. Slobodan sucur, theory, period styles, and comparative literature as discipline page 3 of 18 linguistics and poetics, roman jakobson continues with this thrust towards an autonomous definition of literature, a thrust which is representative of the earlier phase of formalism. This discussion is necessary in order to locate current developments within a. Comparative historical research is a method of social science that examines historical events in order to create explanations that are valid beyond a particular time and place, either by direct comparison to other historical events, theory building, or reference to the present day.
53 1260 1045 1301 1408 106 460 57 448 774 817 468 554 392 527 1144 1489 1189 635 1151 1095 921 870 1255 713 744 1337 95 76 1396 367 724 607 223 1177 1076 155 281 1408 985 529 1260 1359 1108 1365 562